Monday, March 19, 2007

Book Report

I just finished a book about human organ harvesting. It's a popular topic. There have been movies about it and a lot of books.

This one had the bad guys trying to follow Plato's Republic, with the bad guys playing the part of the Guardians. The other two castes were Producers and Auxiliaries. You could Google Plato's Republic and see how this plays out.

The bad guy Guardians were all doctors...transplantation specialists who figured that since they were the ones who did the transplantations, they should have the major say in who got the new organs. There's some merit to this notion, or at the very least, nothing really objectionable to the idea. But that quickly evolved into deciding that if X deserved a transplant, he should get it as soon as possilbe, meaning they had to find and kill a matching donor to get the needed organs. Very logical, if you're monomanical.

The protagonists were three disparate souls, two of whom fall in love. The third, having received the lung of one of the first two, gives back the lung and makes them real Guardians. It was a fun read: The Fifth Vial by Michael Palmer.

3 comments:

Nessa said...

Plato's Republic was interesting. It was so logical, it was almost too hard to argue against the plan. But we all know that people in power reach a certain point where they begin to feel so superior that they believe their own bullshit. Plus, someone, somewhere, will feel the need to breakout of the mold they are put in. Someone always has to mess up the plan.

Michael Palmer's books look interesting. I may have to check them out. I feel the urge to re-read The Republic now.

paperback reader said...

I hate Plato's Republic, though I still use the term "kallipolis" on occasion. I hate the idea that he had no ideas, and only made fun of everyone else's. That's not a system of thought, that's what I do, and no one's reading my diatribes 2,000 years from now.

Bert Bananas said...

Maybe if you didn't call them diatribes... Start calling them soliloquies... They might then become timeless.